Top 7 Best Toasters for Bagels in 2023

There’s something undeniably satisfying about biting into a perfectly toasted bagel. The warm, crispy exterior paired with the soft, chewy interior makes for a delightful breakfast experience. But achieving that perfect toast isn’t always easy, especially when you’re dealing with a subpar toaster. That’s why we’ve taken the time to research and compile a list of the top 7 best toasters for bagels. These toasters not only excel in performance and durability, but they also come with features specifically designed to handle bagels.

So whether you’re a fan of the classic plain bagel or prefer something more adventurous like a cinnamon raisin or everything bagel, these best toasters for bagels will ensure your bagel is toasted to perfection every time.

Understanding the Basics of Toasters

Before we delve into our top picks, it’s essential to understand what makes a great toaster for bagels. Unlike standard bread slices, bagels are denser and often larger, requiring a toaster to accommodate their size and provide the right amount of heat.

Key features to look for include wide slots, adjustable browning settings, and a bagel function. Wide slots are crucial as they allow the bagel to fit comfortably without being squished. Adjustable browning settings let you control how light or dark you want your bagel toasted. And the bagel function is a game-changer – it toasts the cut side of the bagel while warming the round side, giving you a perfectly toasted bagel with a crispy cut side and a warm, soft round side. Understanding these basic features will help you make an informed decision when choosing the best toaster for bagels.

The Importance of Choosing the Right Toaster for Bagels

So when you’re shopping for the best toasters for bagels, don’t just consider the price. Consider the features, the durability, and the ease of use. Because the right toaster can make all the difference.

What Are The Top 7 Best Toasters for Bagels?

Our Top Picks

Before we delve deeper into the full reviews, here are our top picks of the best toasters for bagels:

1. Premium Choice: Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster
2. Best Value: Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster
3. Budget Pick: Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster

Let’s get into the details!

1. Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster

• High lift feature
• LED panel
• Dual independent toast controls

The Breville BTA840XL is not just a toaster; it’s a smart appliance that takes toasting to a whole new level, making it one of the best toasters for bagels. This high-end toaster is a marvel of modern technology, boasting features that make toasting bagels a breeze. The ‘A Bit More’ button is a standout feature, allowing you to add a little extra toasting time to achieve that perfect golden brown. The ‘Lift and Look’ lever is another innovative feature that lets you check on your bagel’s progress without interrupting the toasting cycle.

Constructed from durable die-cast metal, this toaster is built to last, promising years of reliable service. It’s a 4-slice toaster, making it perfect for families or anyone who needs to toast multiple bagels at once. However, it’s worth noting that this toaster is quite large, so it might not be the best choice if you’re short on counter space.

2. Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

• Dual control panels
• Wide toasting slots
• Slide-out crumb tray

The Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster, one of our best toasters for bagels, is a perfect fusion of vintage aesthetics and modern functionality, making it a standout addition to any kitchen decor. This toaster isn’t just a pretty face; it’s packed with features that ensure top-notch performance. One of its key features is the dual control panels, which allow for simultaneous toasting at different settings. This is particularly handy when you’re preparing breakfast for two, and each person prefers their bagels toasted to a different degree.

The toaster’s extra-wide slots are specifically designed to accommodate bagels, ensuring they fit perfectly. The bagel setting further enhances the toasting experience, delivering optimally toasted bagels every time. However, it’s worth noting that some users have reported a slight inconsistency in toasting, particularly with thinner slices of bread. Despite this minor drawback, the Cuisinart CPT-180 is one of the best toasters for bagels and remains a top choice for those seeking a blend of style, versatility, and performance in a toaster.

3. KitchenAid KMT4115SX Stainless Steel Toaster

• Bagel and cancel buttons
• All-metal construction
• Under base cord storage

The KitchenAid KMT4115SX Stainless Steel Toaster, a shining example of the best toasters for bagels, is a testament to KitchenAid’s dedication to delivering high-quality kitchen appliances. This toaster, with its robust performance and long-lasting durability, is a dependable addition to any kitchen setup. Its bagel function is particularly noteworthy, cleverly reducing power on one side to avoid over-toasting, ensuring your bagels are toasted to perfection every time.

Constructed from stainless steel, this toaster, one of our best toasters for bagels, boasts a contemporary, sleek design that complements any kitchen decor. Its durability is a testament to its high-quality construction, promising longevity and reliable performance. However, it’s worth noting that some users have reported the exterior becoming quite warm during operation. Therefore, it’s advisable to handle with care when in use. This toaster is a great choice for those seeking a blend of style, functionality, and durability in their quest for the perfect bagel toasting experience.

4. Smeg 2-Slice Toaster

• Retro 50’s style
• 6 browning levels
• Extra-wide slots

The Smeg 2-Slice Toaster, a remarkable entry in our best toasters for bagels list, is a fusion of vintage charm and modern functionality, making it a standout addition to any kitchen countertop. Its 50’s retro style is a visual delight, but it’s the toaster’s impressive performance that truly sets it apart. With a dedicated bagel function, extra-wide slots to accommodate thick slices and bagels, and six adjustable browning levels, this toaster ensures a flawless toasting experience every time.

However, it’s important to note that the Smeg 2-Slice Toaster falls into the higher price range. If you’re on a tight budget, this might not be the ideal toaster for you. But for those who value quality and aesthetics equally and are ready to invest in a top-notch toaster that delivers both, the Smeg 2-Slice Toaster is a worthy contender. It’s not just a toaster; it’s a statement piece that combines style, performance, and the joy of a perfectly toasted bagel.

5. Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

• Auto shutoff
• Shade selector
• Toast boost

If you’re seeking a cost-effective solution among the best toasters for bagels, the Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster is a commendable option. Despite its budget-friendly price point, it doesn’t compromise on essential features. Equipped with extra-wide slots, it can comfortably accommodate your favorite bagels, ensuring they’re toasted to your exact preference.

One of the standout attributes of this toaster is its compact design. It’s an ideal choice for those who have space constraints in their kitchen. However, it’s worth noting that some users have reported that the toaster’s exterior can become quite warm during operation. Therefore, it’s crucial to exercise caution while handling it.

In conclusion, the Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Toaster is a testament to the fact that you don’t need to break the bank to enjoy perfectly toasted bagels. It’s a reliable, feature-packed, and space-efficient appliance that delivers excellent value for money.

6. Black+Decker 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster

• Extra-wide toasting slots
• Seven toast shades
• Built-in cord storage

The BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster, despite its compact design, packs a punch when it comes to delivering a top-notch toasting experience, making it one of the best toasters for bagels. This small but mighty kitchen gadget is perfect for those who enjoy a thick, hearty bagel for breakfast. Its extra-wide slots are designed to accommodate the thickest of bagels, ensuring they fit comfortably without getting stuck.

The bagel setting on this toaster is a game-changer, providing optimal toasting results that will elevate your breakfast routine. It heats up rapidly, ensuring you don’t have to wait long for your perfectly toasted bagel. The even toasting feature guarantees that your bagels come out just right every time, with a crispy exterior and a soft, warm interior.

However, it’s worth noting that some users have mentioned the cord length could be a bit longer. If your kitchen outlet isn’t within close proximity to your countertop, you might need to consider this. Despite this minor drawback, the BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster remains a solid choice for bagel lovers.

7. Oster 2-Slice Toaster

• Advanced toasting technology
• 7 toast shade settings
• Removable crumb tray

The Oster 2-Slice Toaster, a practical and user-friendly kitchen appliance that provides a variety of toasting possibilities, is one of the best toasters for bagels on our list. Its extra-wide slots are perfect for accommodating bagels, while the adjustable browning control ensures your bagels are toasted to your exact preference.

Cleaning this toaster is a breeze, thanks to its removable crumb tray, a feature that adds to its overall convenience. However, it’s worth noting that some users have reported that the toaster can be somewhat noisy when the toast pops up. This might be a minor inconvenience if you’re particularly sensitive to noise.

Despite this, the Oster 2-Slice Toaster stands out as a dependable and cost-effective choice for toasting bagels. Its combination of functionality and affordability makes it a great addition to any kitchen, especially for those who enjoy a perfectly toasted bagel for breakfast.

How to Choose the Best Toaster for Bagels

When it comes to selecting the perfect toaster from our list of best toasters for bagels, there are several factors you need to consider. From the size of the slots to the ease of cleaning, each aspect plays a crucial role in determining the functionality and convenience of your toaster. Let’s delve deeper into these factors.

Slot Size and Adjustability

The first thing to consider when shopping for a toaster is the size of the slots. Bagels are typically larger and thicker than standard bread slices, so you’ll need a toaster with wide and deep slots to accommodate them. Some toasters, like the Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster, come with extra-wide slots, making them ideal for toasting bagels.

But size isn’t the only thing that matters when it comes to slots. Adjustability is equally important. Look for a toaster with self-centering slots. These slots adjust to the thickness of the bread, ensuring even toasting on both sides. The Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic 4-Slice toaster, for instance, comes with self-adjusting slots that hold the bagels perfectly in place while toasting.

Browning Settings

The browning setting is another critical feature to consider. Everyone has their own preference when it comes to how dark or light they want their bagels toasted. A good toaster should offer a wide range of browning options, allowing you to customize the toasting level to your liking.

The BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster (TR2900SSD) is a great example of a toaster with versatile browning settings. It offers seven toast shades, from light to dark, giving you full control over the browning level.

Bagel Setting

A bagel setting is a must-have feature for any bagel lover. This setting ensures that the cut side of the bagel gets toasted while the round side gets warm. This way, you get a perfectly toasted bagel with a crispy cut side and a soft, warm round side.

The Smeg 2-Slice Toaster features a dedicated bagel function that expertly toasts the inside of the bagel while gently warming the outside, ensuring a flawlessly toasted bagel each time you use it.

Material and Durability

The material of the toaster is another important factor to consider. Not only does it determine the durability of the toaster, but it also affects its appearance. Stainless steel toasters, like the KitchenAid KMT4115SX, are popular for their durability and sleek design. They are resistant to rust and easy to clean, making them a great choice for long-term use.

Ease of Cleaning

Let’s face it, cleaning a toaster can be a hassle. But with the right features, it doesn’t have to be. Look for a toaster with a removable crumb tray. This feature makes cleaning a breeze as it collects all the crumbs that fall off during toasting. Simply slide out the tray, dispose of the crumbs, and slide it back in.

Extra Features

Extra features like defrost, reheat, and cancel buttons add convenience and versatility to your toasting experience. The defrost function allows you to toast frozen bread directly, while the reheat function lets you warm your toast without browning it further. The cancel button is a safety feature that allows you to immediately stop the toasting process.

Frequently Asked Questions

When it comes to toasting bagels, we all have our questions. Here are some of the most common queries about toasters for bagels and their answers.

1. Can I Toast Bagels in a Regular Toaster?

Yes, you can toast bagels in a regular toaster. However, for the best results, it’s recommended to use a toaster with a bagel setting. This ensures the bagel is toasted evenly and to your liking.

2. What is the bagel setting on a toaster?

The bagel setting on a toaster is designed to toast the cut side of the bagel while warming the round side. This results in a bagel with a crispy cut side and a warm, soft round side, which is the ideal texture for most bagel lovers.

3. What’s the Purpose of the Bagel Setting on a Toaster?

The purpose of the bagel setting on a toaster is to provide an optimal toasting experience for bagel lovers. It ensures the bagel is toasted evenly, with a crispy cut side and a soft, warm outer side.

4. How Does the Toaster Bagel Setting Work?

The bagel setting on a toaster works by reducing the heat on one side of the toaster (usually the outer side of the bagel), while the other side (the cut side) gets toasted normally. This results in a bagel that is crispy on the inside and soft on the outside.

5. How do I clean my toaster?

Start by unplugging your toaster and removing the crumb tray. Empty the crumbs and wash the tray with warm soapy water. For the interior, use a soft brush to gently remove any crumbs or residue. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that could damage the toaster.

6. What size slots should I look for in a toaster for bagels?

Look for a toaster with extra-wide slots. This will allow you to easily fit bagels, which are typically thicker than standard bread slices.

7. How do I know what browning setting to use for my bagel?

The browning setting depends on your personal preference. If you prefer a lighter toast, start with a lower setting. If you like your bagel darker, choose a higher setting. It may take a few tries to find your perfect setting.

8. Can I toast frozen bagels in my toaster?

Yes, many toasters come with a defrost function that allows you to toast frozen bread or bagels directly. Always refer to your toaster’s manual for specific instructions.

 9. Why is my toaster smoking?

If your toaster is smoking, it could be due to a build-up of crumbs in the bottom of the toaster. Regularly cleaning your toaster can help prevent this. If the smoking continues, it could be a sign of a more serious issue, and you should stop using the toaster immediately.

10. Can I toast other types of bread in my bagel toaster?

Absolutely! While the extra-wide slots in bagel toasters are perfect for bagels, they can also accommodate other types of bread, English muffins, and even waffles.

Remember, the key to a great toasting experience is not just a high-quality toaster, but also understanding how to use and maintain it properly.

Conclusion: Final Thoughts and Recommendations

Choosing the best toaster for bagels can be a daunting task, given the wide array of options available in the market. However, armed with the right information and understanding of what to look for, you can make an informed decision that suits your needs and preferences.

When it comes to toasting bagels, the size of the slots, the browning settings, and the presence of a bagel setting are crucial factors to consider. The material and durability of the toaster, its ease of cleaning, and any extra features it offers, such as defrost and reheat functions, also play a significant role in determining its overall performance and convenience.

From the high-end Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster with its ‘Lift and Look’ feature to the affordable and reliable BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster, there’s a toaster out there for every bagel lover. Whether you prefer a classic toasted bagel or like to experiment with different types of bagels and toppings, these toasters are designed to deliver the perfect toast every time.

Remember, the best toaster for you, from our list of best toasters for bagels, is one that fits your budget, meets your specific needs, and adds convenience to your daily routine. So, consider your options carefully, keep our tips in mind, and you’ll be on your way to enjoying perfectly toasted bagels in no time.

In the end, it’s all about enjoying your favorite toasted bagels just the way you like them. So, here’s to many mornings of perfectly toasted bagels, made possible by our list of best toasters for bagels, spread with your favorite toppings, and enjoyed with a cup of your favorite coffee. Happy toasting!